“A republic—if
you can keep it,” Benjamin Franklin shot back to the
woman who asked what type of government had been
produced by the Constitutional Convention. Today, as
the Supreme Court hears arguments regarding the
constitutionality of ObamaCare, no truer words have
ever been spoken. Can we keep it? To help you
decipher the censored news reports from Washington,
ponder the following principles underlying our
American republic.
I. Our Declaration of Independence clearly states
our rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of
happiness come directly from God. He gives them and
only He can take them away. If our rights came from
government, they can be instituted or removed
depending upon the whims of rulers. Such was the
case throughout history prior to 1776 when our
founders established our great American experiment
in freedom.
II. The framers of our constitution despised
tyranny, yet they feared democracy because
historically, majority rule always descends back
into tyranny. We democratically elect
representatives to serve in government, but in their
oath of office they pledge to “support protect and
defend the Constitution.” The allegiance of the duly
elected public servant to the rule of law makes us a
constitutional republic, not a democracy.
III. Our Constitution purposely limits government.
American framers knew people in power invariably
thirst for more and the federal government would
become oppressively large. Article I, section 8 of
the Constitution enumerates the limited governing
powers the people granted to Congress. It is all
they are allowed to do. The Tenth Amendment grants
the unmentioned powers, and there could be
thousands, to the states or the people. This
provides a critical vertical balance of power
between the federal and state governments and this
is where the many state legislatures enter the fray.
In consideration to the above points and the
ObamaCare debate consider this:
1. If healthcare is a right, it came from
government, not God, and as such it may be granted
or taken away at the whims of the ruling elite. This
should scare you.
2. Where in Article I, section 8 of the Constitution
did we grant Congress the power to control
healthcare? It’s not there. To stretch the “commerce
clause” around healthcare defies logic, yet if the
Supreme Court rules as such there is no segment of
your life outside the reach of Congress.
3. If the Supreme Court finds the insurance mandate
is constitutional, yet the majority of state
legislatures rule to the contrary, whose opinion is
superior? (You have to think about this one.)
4. If the Supreme Court tosses the case because
ObamaCare is not in full effect until 2013, expect
CNN, MSNBC and all others in the state run media to
spin this as a huge victory for the president. The
heavy lifting of saving our republic then falls on
the shoulders of every state legislator who honors
his oath of office—a job not for the faint of heart.
Can we keep the republic?
|